Two ice cream cartons just waiting for me!
Ben had brought me such a nice surprise!
Two cartons of ice cream right before my eyes.
It wasn't really so, but it seemed to me ...
turns out Ben just put back an empty carton and got my hopes all up. (Sorry I couldn't make this last part fit into the song)
Luckily the other carton of ice cream had enough in it for me to get a decent bowl full.